The buyer says FIRPTA should be 15% of my profit, not 15% of the sales price. Is that right?
I am selling a condo in Florida as a nonresident seller from Germany. The buyer is trying to be cooperative, but they are also using internet summaries that seem to blend final tax with FIRPTA withholding. My actual gain is much smaller than the contract price because I bought years ago and spent a lot on improvements, so the difference matters materially.
What I need is a clean answer about the withholding base at closing. If FIRPTA normally uses amount realized rather than gain, I want the transaction team to stop treating those concepts as interchangeable and either follow the default rule or pursue a proper withholding certificate.
Metered Q&A
Expert answer available
Checking your reading access. The answer will open in full when a free view or membership access is available.
Related Questions
I'm taking $150k cash boot in my exchange — why is withholding on the FULL $2.5M sale price, not just the boot?
My deferred exchange: I'm selling a property for $2.5M and buying a $2.35M replacement, so I get $150k back in cash. Only that $150k is taxable now. So why is everyone telling me FIRPTA withholding is...
IRC 1445 FIRPTA withholding — does the buyer really hold back 15% of the entire sale price when I sell my U.S. property?
I'm a Mexican citizen and I'm selling a condo in Arizona that I hold through my LLC. The title company said they need to withhold 15% of the gross sale price under IRC 1445. The condo is selling for $...
Our Form 8288-B was filed before closing but the IRS has not answered yet. Do we still send the withholding money right away?
The seller is from France and the closing agent filed Form 8288-B because the default FIRPTA amount looks far above the actual likely tax. The application was filed before closing, but we still have n...
The buyer wants to skip FIRPTA because they say the house is a future residence, but they also plan to rent it for a while. Is that still safe?
I am a Canadian seller and the buyer is trying to use the residence exception to avoid withholding. The problem is that in side conversations they also talk about renting the house before eventually m...
Buyer is paying $900k and taking over a $100k mortgage — what's the FIRPTA withholding?
Selling my US property as a non-resident. The buyer is paying me $900,000 in cash and also taking the property subject to my existing $100,000 mortgage. The buyer's lawyer says FIRPTA is 15% but I'm n...
The foreign seller has no ITIN yet. Does that stop the FIRPTA filing?
We are a small title team and the seller is from Mexico. The sale is moving fast, but the seller still does not have an ITIN, and the buyer is asking whether that means the whole FIRPTA package has to...
Are there sale prices where FIRPTA drops to 10% or even zero?
I'm a foreign seller and a friend mentioned that smaller home sales sometimes get a reduced FIRPTA rate, or no withholding at all, if the buyer is moving in. Is that real? What price thresholds matter...
My qualified intermediary holds all the sale funds — doesn't that solve the FIRPTA withholding problem?
In my exchange, the qualified intermediary receives all the net sale proceeds and holds them until I buy the replacement. So I never touch the money. Doesn't that mean there's nothing to withhold FIRP...
Does holding U.S. real estate through an LLC protect me from FIRPTA? My attorney said it would.
I'm a Brazilian citizen looking to buy rental properties in Miami. My attorney in Brazil recommended I set up a Wyoming LLC to hold the properties, saying it would "protect" me from FIRPTA. But I've b...
If my sale is a 1031 exchange, does the FIRPTA 15% withholding still apply?
I keep getting conflicting answers. My closing agent says because it's a like-kind exchange, no FIRPTA withholding is needed. My CPA partner says it depends. Who is right? I'm a foreign person selling...
Have a similar question?
ForeignLLCTax members get expert answers with IRS citations. One CPA consultation costs $200+. Full access is $9.99/month.
Become a Member — $9.99/moDisclaimer: All content on ForeignLLCTax.com is created by a tax professional and is provided for general educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute tax, legal, or accounting advice, and should not be relied upon as such. Every tax situation is different — for advice specific to your circumstances, please consult a licensed CPA, Enrolled Agent, or tax attorney. By using this website, purchasing a subscription, or accessing any tools or services, you acknowledge that no client-professional relationship is established between you and ForeignLLCTax.com or its operators. This website is not affiliated with the IRS.
