My advisor says the treaty protects me, but do I actually need Form 8833 if no U.S. tax ends up due?
I am in France and use a Delaware LLC for consulting. My advisor says the treaty should protect me because there is no permanent establishment in the U.S., and that my U.S. tax may be reduced to zero on that position. I assumed that if the treaty gets me to zero, there would be nothing extra to file.
Now I am hearing that Form 8833 may still be required just to disclose the treaty position. I want to know whether this is real or whether people are being overly cautious.
Related Questions
If I am claiming treaty residency in Canada, does Form 8833 have to go in with a timely 1040-NR?
I spent enough time in the U.S. to create a real residency question, but my position is that the Canada treaty tie-breaker keeps me resident in Canada for treaty purposes. I know Form 8833 is part of ...
My software ignored Form 8801 because I do not owe AMT this year. Is that a mistake if I paid AMT before?
I paid AMT in a prior year because of timing issues, but the current-year return does not generate AMT. My software is acting like that means the topic is over and no form is needed. A different advis...
My spouse and child were here with me in F-2 status and had no income. Do they still need their own Form 8843 filings?
I understood my own filing better than I understood the family side of it. Because neither my spouse nor child had any income, I had assumed their part of the tax picture was automatically blank. Then...
Our software pulled in a prior-year foreign tax credit carryover, but I do not see Schedule B attached. Is that a problem?
I am a U.S. citizen living in the UK, and this year's Form 1116 includes a carryover from a prior year where the passive basket was limited. The tax software reflected the amount on line 10, but when ...
I paid several LLC bills personally and never reimbursed myself. Does that still need a clean Form 5472 story?
I live in Colombia and my Delaware LLC was underfunded for most of the year, so I kept paying subscriptions, contractors, and filing fees from my personal foreign cards. I never reimbursed myself beca...
I became a U.S. resident mid-year and now have contract income with no withholding. Do the normal estimated tax due dates still apply?
I am from the Netherlands and became a U.S. resident during 2025. After the move I stopped being paid through payroll and instead started billing clients through my U.S. LLC. There is no U.S. withhold...
All the source documents exist, but there is no index tying them to the filed Form 5472. Is that still an audit problem?
Our file is not empty at all. In fact, it is almost the opposite problem: there is a large volume of supporting material, but nothing that clearly points from the filed numbers to the exact folders an...
I keep hearing about Schedule C, but my foreign-owned LLC adviser says it may not apply to me at all
I am in Brazil and own a single-member U.S. LLC. Generic LLC content online keeps telling me Schedule C is the standard return for a one-owner business. My U.S. adviser says that is domestic content a...
I keep wiring money from my personal foreign account into the LLC. How do I decide whether that was capital or a loan for Form 5472?
I live in Brazil and own a single-member Delaware LLC. Over the last year I sent several personal wires into the company to cover software bills, contractors, and a few large formation costs. I never ...
I claimed foreign tax credits on an accrued basis in my workpapers but forgot the election statement. Did I actually make the election?
I am a U.S. resident founder living in France, and in our 2025 workpapers we computed the foreign tax credit using accrued taxes because the French assessment cycle lags behind payment timing. My retu...
Have a similar question?
ForeignLLCTax members get expert answers with IRS citations. One CPA consultation costs $200+. Full access is $9.99/month.
Become a Member — $9.99/moDisclaimer: All content on ForeignLLCTax.com is created by a tax professional and is provided for general educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute tax, legal, or accounting advice, and should not be relied upon as such. Every tax situation is different — for advice specific to your circumstances, please consult a licensed CPA, Enrolled Agent, or tax attorney. By using this website, purchasing a subscription, or accessing any tools or services, you acknowledge that no client-professional relationship is established between you and ForeignLLCTax.com or its operators. This website is not affiliated with the IRS.
