IRS Compliance & PenaltiesAnswered

Does the FIRPTA buyer really withhold 15% of the whole price at the first payment?

A2
amara_2c55new member
May 19, 2026 1,790 views 1 answer
installment-salefirptaform-8288-bwithholding

I'm selling US real estate to a US buyer on installments. My buyer's attorney says they have to withhold 15% of the entire sale price out of the first payment, but my down payment is small and that withholding is more than the cash changing hands. Is that right, or should it be 15% of each installment?

Related Questions

ComplianceAnswered

Selling my property LLC with 20% down and four annual payments — buyer says all the FIRPTA tax is withheld NOW?

I'm a foreign seller. My disregarded LLC holds a US commercial property, and the buyer and I agreed on an installment deal: 20% at closing, the rest over four years. I expected tax (and withholding) t...

W4
wei_4f8a·May 25, 2026
1,6701
ComplianceAnswered

Selling my 40% of a two-member US LLC — what does section 864(c)(8) actually do to my gain?

Our LLC has two foreign members and files Form 1065 as a partnership. I'm selling my 40% interest to a US buyer. I assumed my gain would be foreign-source capital gain with no US tax, but the buyer's ...

DB
dmitri_b2c5·May 15, 2026
1,9601
ComplianceAnswered

Can I use the installment method when I sell my interest in a US partnership/LLC?

I'm a foreign partner selling my interest in a US LLC taxed as a partnership, with the price paid over three years. Can I report on the installment method, and is there any withholding on the sale lik...

D9
diego_9f33·May 23, 2026
1,3801
ComplianceAnswered

My disregarded LLC's only asset is a US rental condo — if I sell the LLC, is that a real estate sale for tax?

I'm a nonresident and my single-member LLC holds one Florida rental condo and a small bank account. A buyer offered to purchase the LLC itself — the agent says that way 'it's a company sale, not a pro...

R5
rajan_5e77·May 19, 2026
2,3801
ComplianceAnswered

Our closing agent used a FIRPTA exception certification but never sent the required copy to the IRS. Does that break the exception?

The transaction relied on an exception to withholding and everyone was relieved to avoid moving a large amount of cash at closing. Only afterward did we learn that the regulations may have required th...

TC
tomas_c7f3·Dec 10, 2025
1,5791
ComplianceAnswered

I have a large seller note — what are the section 453A interest charge and pledge rule?

I sold a US business and I'm carrying a big seller note. Someone mentioned a section 453A 'interest charge' and a 'pledge rule' if I borrow against the note. When do those kick in, and what happens if...

S6
sven_6b21·May 27, 2026
1,0601
ComplianceAnswered

Real-estate-heavy partnership LLC: buyer's counsel says FIRPTA and 1446(f) both apply — do we stack 15% plus 10%?

I'm a foreign member selling my interest in a US LLC taxed as a partnership. Most of its value is a commercial building. The buyer's lawyer flagged that a FIRPTA rule for partnership interests AND the...

E9
elif_91c0·May 21, 2026
9801
ComplianceAnsweredFeatured

I'm selling my US rental on a payment plan — can I spread the tax with the installment method?

I'm a non-resident and I'm selling a US rental property to a buyer who'll pay me over five years. Can I use the installment method so I only pay US tax on the gain as the payments come in, instead of ...

L4
lukas_4d12·May 9, 2026
1,5101
ComplianceAnswered

Selling my partnership-LLC interest at a loss — can I stop the buyer from withholding 10%?

I'm exiting a US partnership-taxed LLC and will actually realize a small loss on the sale. The buyer's attorney still wants to withhold 10% of the price 'to be safe' under section 1446(f). Tying up th...

I7
ingrid_77b3·May 17, 2026
1,1201
ComplianceAnswered

How is the gross-profit percentage on Form 6252 actually calculated?

I keep reading about a 'gross-profit ratio' on the installment sale. How do I actually compute it, and how does the mortgage the buyer is assuming affect it? I want to estimate how much of each paymen...

P7
priya_7a90·May 14, 2026
1,2401

Have a similar question?

ForeignLLCTax members get expert answers with IRS citations. One CPA consultation costs $200+. Full access is $9.99/month.

Become a Member — $9.99/mo

Disclaimer: All content on ForeignLLCTax.com is created by a tax professional and is provided for general educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute tax, legal, or accounting advice, and should not be relied upon as such. Every tax situation is different — for advice specific to your circumstances, please consult a licensed CPA, Enrolled Agent, or tax attorney. By using this website, purchasing a subscription, or accessing any tools or services, you acknowledge that no client-professional relationship is established between you and ForeignLLCTax.com or its operators. This website is not affiliated with the IRS.

Watch the walkthroughs